Priest Personnel Files – And Why Everyone Should Care …

The theology of priest personnel files in the Roman Catholic Church is oddly similar to its theology of sex.  Even though the creation and maintenance of priest files are natural and good in order to administer the church, church officials blush and bristle in acknowledging they exist.

The files have all sorts of names from Diocese to Diocese and Religious Order to Religious Order: 489 files, sub secreto files, personal files, and Hell files.  But what doesn’t change is the detail contained in the files that the Hierarchy wants to abstain from discussing or showing to federal prosecutors, sex crimes detectives, and survivors of rape and sodomy who have settled righteous claims.

That is why the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision not to consider the Diocese of Bridgeport’s appeal to keep the documents sealed is so historically important.

Priest personnel files are important for several reasons:

First, they detail every contact the diocese or religious order has with the priest or religious. Whether it is the first contact with the vocations director, a complaint from the pastor who again caught a child in the cleric’s room, a complaint from a nurse on the pediatric ward, or a letter of praise from a Grandma McDonough, every piece of correspondence is preserved.

Second, church archivists and historians consistently teach that the past is prologue to the future. If a Priest or Religious or lay volunteer sexually abuses a child, there exists a criminal psychic infirmity in that person’s very nature – a zebra cannot change its stripes.  Father Gerald Fitzgerald, S.P. told the Popes and Bishops in the 1940s, 1950s and 60s that these vipers cannot be placed back in ministry.  As a result, Popes Pius XII, John XXIII, and Paul VI allowed Father Fitzgerald to create worldwide treatment centers for priest offenders.

Third, priest personnel records contain the materials and evidence demonstrating what the Hierarchy knew and when they were aware of the priest’s or religious’ pedophilic and
ephebophilic behaviors. One study by Robert Camargo and John Loftus reviewed 1,322 clerics treated at the Southdown Institute.  Another study by the John Jay College of Criminal Justice found that 4,392 priests were credibly accused of sexually abusing children in the U.S.  Not surprisingly, only 3,250 of those 4,392 have been disclosed.  Where are the remaining 1,142?  It’s in the files …

Fourth, Reverend Canice Connors, OFM told the Milwaukee Journal and reported to the Bishops at the 1993 annual meeting, “The Catholic Church in North America possesses the greatest data bank of evaluation and treatment of non-incarcerated pedophiles on the continent.  That data should be analyzed scientifically and shared with others studying the problem.” The study, which was 86% completed, had it funding pulled and the data and preliminary conclusions were never disseminated.

The Hierarchy at the Dallas 2002 meeting hollowly proclaimed a new age of transparency in order to protect children.  By the Hierarchy’s actions and inactions, this transparency apparently does not include the most crucial historical documents: priest personnel files.  As we follow the news and see new priests and bishops arrested, I have to conclude the Hierarchy has lost control of the institution.  Thus the sad time has come for every Archdiocese, Diocese, and Religious Order in litigation to turn over all their personnel files (past and present) for public review.

Since there is nothing to hide behind and there is little else more important than the safety and protection of children, it is time for the Hierarchy to follow the directives of the U.S. Supreme Court and turn over priest personnel files to prosecutors, detectives and survivors.  Like sex, the Hierarchy has the priest personnel files issue all backwards: The real scandal and destruction to the church’s reputation is secretly hiding the facts and not analyzing the causes and prevention of clerical sexual abuse for future generations.



Filed under Uncategorized

4 responses to “Priest Personnel Files – And Why Everyone Should Care …

  1. smpturlish


    I have been praying to God that the United States Supreme Court would make the right decision regarding the Bridgeport Diocese’s appeal to keep their documents sealed, and it has.

    Now perhaps we will learn how the decisions to protect abusive priests instead of children were made and by whom.

    Accountability for the present and the future does not absolve one from the obligation of accountability for the crimes and sins of the past.

    Sister Maureen Paul Turlish
    Victims’ Advocate
    New Castle, Delaware

  2. bostonpadre

    Many years ago, when I was first ordained, whenever the church faced “troubled times” there was the joke of keeping score: Lions 10 Christians 0

    Now it seems it’s THE GOOD GUYS (Victims) 1 and HIERACRCHY 0 !!!!!!!!!!

    Now hopefully we can get to the REAL truth and clear out all the misleading and misinformed hierarchy and get this right this time!
    Fr. Jim
    Priest and Victim

  3. hrharvat

    Too bad this can’t include all those sent to the Papal Nuncio (for safekeeping!) and the stacks that were shredded.

  4. d379

    Too bad all the priests sent to the Vatican cannot be extradited for their crimes also along with the pandora’s box of files.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s