Bishops Gone Wild

Think that Kansas City Bishop Robert Finn’s recent guilty plea is a shock to Rome? Alas, for the Holy See, this is nothing new.  The real question in the case of the Kansas City Bishop is: What options does the Holy See have available?

From the Roman viewpoint, this is a delicate balancing act.  On one side, the Holy See does not want to concede to the “people” demanding the removal of Finn. Why? Because it is reminiscent of 19th century Lay Trusteeism.  On the other side, the embarrassment of how Finn handled the Shawn Ratigan case (nearly ten years after the Charter and Norms were promulgated) is scandalous.

Here is a list of management techniques deployed by the Holy See in recent history to snuff out scandal created by Bishops.  The management techniques fall into two categories: Geographic and Privation of Office.

Geographic Solution

As a new priest twenty years ago, I saw the results of the Vatican quietly removing Bishop Lawrence Welsh of Spokane, WA.

Larry sexually assaulted a teenage prostitute in Chicago while at a Knights of Columbus convention.  Larry was the national Chaplain to the Knights.  Chicago police investigated and the Spokane newspaper exposed it.

The Holy See acted quickly, neutralizing the scandal by saying that Welsh was arrested for drunk driving and applying the “Geographic Solution.”  Larry was removed as the Ordinary of Spokane and relocated to Saint Paul/Minneapolis.

Privation of Office

The privation of office is a management technique that has at least eight different tactics.  The first is to transfer the bishop to the “missions” on another continent.  Second is to remove and sometimes invalidate his episcopal ordination.  A third common technique is to send the bishop for chemical addiction treatment (see Welsh above).  Fourth is to order the bishop attend a sexual abuse treatment program.  Fifth is the traditional solution of ordering the bishop to a life of prayer and penance in a monastery.  Sixth is to send the bishop to become a chaplain in a remote area.  Seventh is to quietly retire him to an emeritus status.  Lastly, they’ll jet the guy out of town and transfer him to Rome.

Here are more than a few examples of canon 416 (privation of office) actions that Rome has performed on members of the Hierarchy of recent memory:

a.  Bishop Lawrence Welsh of Spokane was removed, sent to “alcohol treatment,” and transferred to be an Auxiliary Bishop in Saint Paul, Minnesota.

b.  Bishop Emerson Moore of New York was removed and sent to Hazelden.  Bishop Moore died in an AIDS hospice in Stillwater, Minnesota.

c.  Bishop Thomas Dupre of Springfield, Mass was removed and sent to Saint Luke Institute.

d.  Bishop Anthony J. O’Connell of Jefferson City, MO was removed and sent to live a life of prayer and penance at Mepkin Abbey.

e.  Archbishop Robert Sanchez of Santa Fe was removed and sent to be a chaplain at a small convent of Hispanic nuns in southwestern Minnesota with summers in Anchorage.

f.  Bishop G. Patrick Ziemann of Santa Rosa, CA was removed and sent to live in a house on the grounds of a Benedictine monastery in Tucson.

g.  Several Bishops immediately resigned upon allegations of moral turpitude and then they remained as bishop emeritus.  Bishop Kendrick Williams of Lexington Ky.  Bishop Joseph Symons of Palm Beach, FL.  Bishop Timothy Harrington of Worcester, Mass.  Bishop Christopher Weldon of Springfield Mass.

h.  Abbot Laurence Soper O.S.B. was removed and sent to Rome.  Now he has an interpol arrest warrant out for his arrest for failure to appear on child abuse allegations in the U.K.

i.  Abbot John Eidenschink O.S.B. was removed and made a chaplain in a tiny town in northern minnesota.

More stories could be recounted but the evidence is substantial. The Holy See—through its many Vatican offices—has the power, authority and knowledge of what to do.

As to Bishop Finn?  Let’s spin the wheel. Since he has a criminal record (unlike many of his counterparts above) we may all end up being surprised.


Filed under canon law, catholic, clergy abuse, Clergy Sex Abuse

6 responses to “Bishops Gone Wild

  1. And here I thought Three-Card Monte was a mind-bender!

  2. Love it Patrick, love it!!! You couldn’t have picked a better title.

  3. glorybe1929

    I have been blogging about the “EVILS “of the Mighty RomanCatholicChurch for 11 yrs and not much has really been happened until now.!
    It seems people’s eyes are being opened by the constant lies and subtrefuge going on with these supposed( holy?) people. (priests, nuns and brothers,taught by the Hierarachy, how to get away with their evil deeds, to OUR children, handicapped and marginalized.) We spent over 60 yrs believing this “evil for good” ,worse than trash from a group of Demons. NO MORE!
    My prayer is; “Please God Stop this evil TELL THE PEOPLE TO STOP GOING TO THIS place.”

  4. I’d rather have a crack house next store than a catholic bishop living next to my family.

  5. This site is important to anyone who was sexually abused by former catholic priest John Wellinger or any priest from the Pittsburgh Diocese. Douglas Nowicki was the secretary for education in the Pittsburgh Diocese. Nowicki would have been aware of any alleged sexual abuse of innocent children and would have been aware of any alleged cover up. He may even have been one of the first persons informed of any harm done to a innocent child in a catholic school in the Pittsburgh Diocese during his reign as secretary of educaton.

    I had first-hand experience with Nowicki, like so many other catholic clerics, Nowicki was a schmuck and scoundrel. Read this letter and make your own decision.

  6. John Candido

    Dear Sir/Madam,

    I have initiated an online petition through in order for Pope Benedict XVI to authorise an independent, international, commission of inquiry concerning the global clerical sexual abuse of children, which is plaguing the entire Roman Catholic Church. If you agree with the sentiments of my petition, which includes the reform of sexual doctrine, and for the development of global policies and regulations, to protect all children and vulnerable people from potential abusers, through new articles of Canon Law etc., can you please consider adding your signature to it?

    Can you also pass on my petition to any other person or group of people who might be interested in its aims? I would be very appreciative if you could do this for the promotion of the petition. Please click on the link below to view the petition. Thank you very much for your time.

    Sincerely yours, John Candido.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s